Cozy Mystery Series Starters Part 1.

Cozy Mysteries are characteristically easy reads. Nothing too intense or too serious. Just a good old fashioned sleuthing to curl up with on a rainy day. I will say that they often take on a food or hobby theme. When I first started working at the library, the first thing I noticed about cozy mysteries is that their titles made me hungry, particularly for sweets! Thanks Joanne Fluke..

Death of a Gossip by MC Beaton

Hamish Macbeth Mysteries

Commitment Level: 37 books

Highland cop Hamish Macbeth must uncover who had enough motive to strangle and drown Jane Winters, a tabloid reporter notorious for exposing others’ secrets. The story unfolds partly through a naive secretary’s eyes, with assistance from aristocratic Priscilla Halburton-Smythe.

Find the series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/b/m-c-beaton/

The Quiche of Death by MC Beaton

Agatha Raisin Mysteries

Commitment Level: 35 books

Agatha Raisin leaves her successful PR career, sells her London apartment, and tries early retirement in the quiet village of Carsely. Feeling bored and lonely, she enters a local baking contest, hoping to make a name for herself. But her plans take a dark turn when Judge Cummings-Browne not only dismisses her entry but ends up dead from poisoning.

Find the series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/b/m-c-beaton/

Carbs and Cadavers by Ellery Adams

Supper Club Mystery

Commitment Level: 7 books

Divorced, shy, and living with his widowed father, former English professor James “Professor Puff” Henry joins a dieter’s supper club called the “Flab Five” to improve his social life and lose weight. In their fried-food-loving town, the group’s focus shifts when a mysterious death disrupts the community. Together, they juggle weight loss and solving the crime that has shaken their small town.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/a/ellery-adams/

A Killer Collection by Ellery Adams

Antiques & Collectibles Mystery

Commitment Level: 9 books

Molly Appleby, a writer for Collector’s Weekly, heads to North Carolina to cover a kiln opening, only to find herself investigating the death of ruthless collector George-Bradley Staunton. As more bodies appear, Molly uncovers fierce rivalries and secrets in the antiques world, where her story may end in danger. This revised edition of the book was originally published under J.B. Stanley’s name.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/a/ellery-adams/

Pies and Prejudice by Ellery Adams

Charmed Pie Shoppe Mystery

Commitment Level: 5 books

After catching her husband cheating, Ella Mae LaFaye returns to Havenwood, Georgia, where she discovers her pies have magical effects on those who eat them. She opens the Charmed Pie Shoppe, but when her old rival’s fiancé is found dead, Ella Mae must use her newfound magic to clear her name.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/a/ellery-adams/

Wish You Were Here by Rita Mae Brown

Mrs Murphy

Commitment Level: 33 books

In Crozet, Virginia, postmistress Harry Haristeen and her pets—Mrs. Murphy the cat and Tucker the Corgi—are drawn into a murder mystery when residents start receiving ominous postcards before turning up dead. As Harry investigates, unaware that her clever pets are sniffing out clues, they race to protect her from becoming the next target. If only Mrs. Murphy could somehow warn her human friend in time.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/b/rita-mae-brown/

Thyme of Death Susan Wittig Albert

China Bayles

Commitment Level: 29 books

When her friend Jo dies in an apparent suicide, ex-lawyer and herb shop owner China Bayles suspects foul play and begins investigating. As she digs deeper into the secrets of Pecan Springs, Texas, China becomes certain that someone in the close-knit town is hiding a deadly secret.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/a/susan-wittig-albert/

The Darling Dahlias and the Cucumber Tree by Susan Wittig Albert

Darling Dahlias

Commitment Level: 10 books

The ladies of Darling, Alabama, are committed to keeping their town charming. The Darling Dahlias garden club is thriving—until they hear rumors of bank troubles, an escaped convict, and a mysterious ghost digging near their tree. If anyone can unearth the truth, it’s the Darling Dahlias.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/a/susan-wittig-albert/

The Diva Runs Out of Time by Krista Davis

Domestic Diva

Commitment Level: 18 books

Natasha Smith is the queen of entertaining, but her childhood rival, Sophie Winston, is eager to outshine her—especially in the upcoming Stupendous Stuffing Shakedown. Though Natasha has taken the spotlight and even Sophie’s husband, Sophie is determined to win the contest with the perfect ingredient.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/d/krista-davis/

Murder, She Barked by Krista Davis

Paws and Claws Mystery

Commitment Level: 10 books

The Sugar Maple Inn in Wagtail, Virginia, is a top destination for pet owners, but when a hit-and-run death occurs, it’s clear something sinister is afoot. Holly Miller, with her new dog and a meddling ex-girlfriend around, returns home to the inn, where she and her furry friends must uncover the truth behind the suspicious death. Together, they’ll sniff out the killer before anyone else gets hurt.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/d/krista-davis/

Borrower of the Night by Elizabeth Peters

Vicky Bliss

Commitment Level: 6 books

Vicky Bliss, an art historian with a knack for solving dangerous mysteries, is drawn to a missing masterpiece hidden in a medieval German castle. Alongside an arrogant colleague, Vicky ventures into Rothenburg, where the search for the treasure soon turns deadly. As secrets and dangers unfold, Vicky must confront either a supernatural evil or a ruthless killer determined to stop her.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/p/elizabeth-peters/

The Seventh Sinner by Elizabeth Peters

Jacqueline Kirby

Commitment Level: 4 books

Jean Suttman thought studying in Rome would be a dream come true, but things take a dark turn when she stumbles upon the body of a despised fellow student in an ancient temple. As accidents begin to plague her, Jean becomes increasingly convinced that someone is intent on harming her. With only the perceptive Jacqueline Kirby to help, Jean realizes there’s nowhere to run—death may be her only escape.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/p/elizabeth-peters/

Crocodile on the Sandbank by Elizabeth Peters

Amelia Peabody

Commitment Level: 20 books

Amelia Peabody, a self-assured Victorian adventurer, begins her first Egyptian journey with her journal and trusty umbrella, rescuing the abandoned Evelyn Barton-Forbes along the way. Together, they join the Emerson brothers at an archaeological site, where mysterious accidents and a botched kidnapping lead Amelia to suspect a dangerous plot against Evelyn. Now, Amelia must confront hidden enemies and dark forces that threaten to make her debut trip her last.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/p/elizabeth-peters/

Maid of Murder by Amanda Flower

India Hayes Mystery

Commitment Level: 2 books

In MAID OF MURDER, college librarian and reluctant bridesmaid India Hayes becomes an amateur sleuth when her childhood friend is murdered, and her brother is framed for the crime. To clear his name, India must find the real killer while navigating quirky family members, college politics, and a police detective’s unexpected interest in her.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/f/amanda-flower/

A Plain Death by Amanda Flower

Appleseed Creek Mystery

Commitment Level: 4 books

In Appleseed Creek, 24-year-old Chloe Humphrey, a tech expert, moves to Ohio’s Amish country and finds herself involved in a murder mystery when her friend Becky, driving Chloe’s car, accidentally kills an Amish elder. As the accident is revealed to be sabotage, Chloe, with the help of Becky’s brother Timothy, must uncover the real target before the killer strikes again.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/f/amanda-flower/

Crime and Poetry by Amanda Flower

Magical Bookshop Mystery

Commitment Level: 5 books

In Charming Books, Violet Waverly returns to her hometown to find her grandmother, Daisy, healthy and determined to keep Violet working at their magical bookstore. When a man is found dead clutching a book from the store and Daisy becomes a suspect, Violet must solve the mystery, aided by a clever cat named Emerson, to clear her grandmother’s name.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/f/amanda-flower/

Assaulted Caramel by Amanda Flower

Amish Candy Shop Mystery

Commitment Level: 9 books

In Swissmen Sweets, chocolatier Bailey King leaves her job in New York to help her grandparents in Harvest, Ohio, only to discover a dead developer in their candy shop with her grandfather’s chocolate knife as the weapon. To clear her grandfather’s name, Bailey must unravel the mystery while navigating danger and an attractive deputy’s assistance.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/f/amanda-flower/

Matchmaking can be Murder by Amanda Flower

Amish Matchmaker Mystery

Commitment Level: 5 books

In Matchmaking Can Be Murder, widowed quiltmaker Millie Fisher returns to Harvest, Ohio, and intervenes when her niece Edith plans to marry the wrong man, Zeke Miller. When Zeke turns up dead in Edith’s greenhouse, Millie must solve the murder to protect her niece and her own reputation before the killer strikes again.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/f/amanda-flower/

Farm to Trouble by Amanda Flower

Farm to Table Mystery

Commitment Level: 4 books

In Farm to Trouble, Shiloh Bellamy returns to Michigan to turn her family farm into an organic operation, only for her investor to be found dead shortly after signing their contract. With her father a prime suspect and the town gossiping, Shiloh must solve the murder to clear her family’s name and save her farm dreams.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/f/amanda-flower/

Aunt Dimity’s Death by Nancy Atherton

Aunt Dimity

Commitment Level: 25 books

Lori Shepherd, struggling with her luck, always believed Aunt Dimity was just a fictional character from her mother’s bedtime stories. That changes when the law firm Willis & Willis presents her with the chance of a substantial inheritance—provided she uncovers the secret hidden in the letters between Dimity and her mother. Includes a one-page recipe for Beth’s Oatmeal Cookies.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/a/nancy-atherton/

Murder Past Due by Miranda James

Cat in the Stacks Mystery

Commitment Level: 17 books

In Athena, Mississippi, librarian Charlie Harris and his Maine coon cat, Diesel, become an unlikely detective duo when Charlie’s famous former classmate, novelist Godfrey Priest, is murdered. To solve the crime, Charlie and Diesel must delve into the town’s history to uncover the killer.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/j/miranda-james/

Bless Her Dead Little Heart by Miranda James

Southern Ladies Mystery

Commitment Level: 4 books

In Southern Double Cross, sisters An’gel and Dickce Ducote find themselves embroiled in a mystery when their former sorority sister, Rosabelle Sultan, arrives with her troublesome children. As tensions over her will escalate, murder strikes, and the sisters must use their Southern wit to unmask a killer among duplicitous suspects.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/j/miranda-james/

Mistletoe Murder by Leslie Meier

Lucy Stone Mystery

Commitment Level: 31 books

In Mistletoe Murders, Lucy Stone juggles holiday preparations and a night job at the mail-order company Country Cousins when she discovers the company’s wealthy founder, Sam Miller, dead in his car from an apparent suicide. Suspecting murder, Lucy dives into a web of secrets and lies, but as Christmas nears, she finds herself dangerously close to uncovering a killer who won’t stop until everyone, including her, is on their list.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/m/leslie-meier/

Murder is Binding by Lorna Barrett

Booktown Mystery

Commitment Level: 18 books

In Murder is Binding, Tricia Miles, owner of a mystery bookstore in Stoneham, New Hampshire, is shocked when her rival, Doris Gleason, is found murdered with a carving knife. As suspicion falls on Tricia due to Doris’s rare cookbook, she must solve the crime and prove her innocence before the killer strikes again.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/b/lorna-barrett/

A Catered Murder by Isis Crawford

Mystery with Recipes

Commitment Level: 19 books

Bernadette Simmons moves back to New York after leaving her cheating boyfriend in L.A. and ends up working for her sister Libby’s catering business. When a high school reunion dinner with a “Dracula” theme turns deadly after bestselling author Laird Wrenn drops dead, the sisters must team up to clear Libby’s name and solve the murder before someone else bites the dust.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/c/isis-crawford/

Murder with Peacocks by Donna Andrews

Meg Langslow

Commitment Level: 37 books

Meg Langslow, maid of honor for three weddings in her small Virginia town, is overwhelmed by eccentric brides and their outrageous demands. Amidst the chaos, a troublesome newcomer is found dead, and Meg must juggle wedding plans with investigating a string of suspicious accidents before the next event turns deadly.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/a/donna-andrews/

You’ve Got Murder by Donna Andrews

Turing Hopper

Commitment Level: 4 books

Turing Hopper, an Artificial Intelligence Personality, is in distress when her creator, Zack, misses work for several days. Despite exhausting all her resources, Turing refuses to give up, sensing foul play—a rare trait for an AIP. Though her deductive skills are impeccable, catching a human criminal will require more than just digital prowess.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/a/donna-andrews/

Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder by Joanne Fluke

Hannah Swensen Mystery

Commitment Level: 30 books

In Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder, Hannah Swensen, a red-haired baker in Lake Eden, Minnesota, becomes an amateur sleuth when the delivery man from Cozy Cow Dairy is found murdered behind her bakery, with her famous cookies scattered around the scene. Determined to clear her name and protect her bakery’s reputation, Hannah digs into a web of suspects, uncovering secrets and motives in her small town. This delicious mystery marks the start of a popular series filled with suspense, humor, and mouthwatering recipes.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/f/joanne-fluke/

Death by Darjeeling by Laura Childs

Tea Shop Mysteries

Commitment Level: 29 books

Theodosia, owner of Charleston’s Indigo Tea Shop, is catering the annual garden party when a respected guest is found dead, clutching an empty teacup. With all eyes on her, Theo must clear her name and uncover the real killer before anyone else’s cup is permanently emptied.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/c/laura-childs/

Keepsake Crimes by Laura Childs

Scrapbooking Mysteries

Commitment Level: 16 books

Carmela Bertrand, owner of a scrapbooking shop in New Orleans, is known for creating elegant designs for her clients’ albums. However, when she comes across a clue hidden in one of their scrapbooks, it leads her to a shocking discovery—a murder.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/c/laura-childs/

Eggs in Purgatory by Laura Childs

Cackleberry Club Mystery

Commitment Level: 9 books

In The Cackleberry Club, Suzanne, Toni, and Petra, three widows who opened a café for support and fresh-baked goods, find themselves at the center of a murder mystery when a lawyer is found dead behind their café. As Suzanne digs into the case, she uncovers a scandal tied to her late husband’s past and becomes entangled with a runaway cultist, putting her own life in danger.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/c/laura-childs/

The Inspector and Mrs. Jeffries by Emily Brightwell

Mrs Jeffries

Commitment Level: 41 books

As housekeeper to Scotland Yard Inspector Witherspoon, Mrs. Jeffries oversees a team of informal investigators, including coachman Smythe, maid Betsy, footman Wiggins, and the arthritic cook, Mrs. Goodge. When wealthy widow and experienced nurse Luty Bell Crookshank is certain that the miserly, incompetent blackmailer Dr. Slocum didn’t die from mushroom soup at a neighborhood luncheon, she begins to investigate the true cause of his death.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/b/emily-brightwell/

Outfoxed by Rita Mae Brown

Jane Arnold

Commitment Level: 16 books

In the elite world of Virginia foxhunting, revered hunt master Jane “Sister” Arnold faces a bitter rivalry between two contenders vying to succeed her. When murder disrupts the prestigious Jefferson Hunt Club, Sister, with the help of clever hounds and foxes, must unravel the mystery to expose dark secrets hiding in her Southern community. Outfoxed brings together lively human and animal characters in a suspenseful tale only Rita Mae Brown could craft.

Find series order at https://www.fantasticfiction.com/b/rita-mae-brown/

Leave a comment